The Elephant Elephant EP is the debut release by Evelyn Evelyn. It was first sold to the public on September 13, 2007 and consists of a 3-song 7" single and a 6-track "bonus" CD (as well as a sticker of a conjoined elephant). The vinyl has full fidelity, while the online/streaming and CD versions of the songs have been run through computer filters to create the sound of an old-time radio transcription. However, the song "Elephant Elephant" is the same on in all variations. "Have You Seen My Sister Evelyn?" appears online and as part of "Goodnight Evelyn" in an alternate form than on vinyl. All of the other tracks are exclusive to their particular formats. "Love Will Tear Us Apart", "Elephant Elephant", "Have You Seen My Sister Evelyn?", and "Sandy's Theme" (with added vocals and under the title "Sandy Fishnets") also appear on their 2010 debut album, Evelyn Evelyn, all of which were re-recorded for the album.